Top 10 3 Bedroom house for sale with den SHELTER ISLAND NY | RENTOCULAR

Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny
Filter

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 79656280

$1,250,000
Shelter Island, NY

appliances
backyard
den
garden
granite counter

3 Bedroom
1 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 80829531

$1,599,000
Shelter Island, NY

appliances
backyard
den
garden
granite counter

3 Bedroom
2.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 75503032

$1,675,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
hardwood floor

3 Bedroom
2.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 78477805

$1,750,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace

3 Bedroom
3.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 80397007

$1,850,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace
waterfront

3 Bedroom
2 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 81262027

$1,850,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace
waterfront

3 Bedroom
2 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 80396959

$1,950,000
Shelter Island, NY

den

5 Bedroom
3 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 81261980

$1,950,000
Shelter Island, NY

den

5 Bedroom
3 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 80566954

$2,000,000
Shelter Island, NY

appliances
balcony
den
ensuite
fireplace

3 Bedroom
2.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 81261915

$2,050,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace

4 Bedroom
4 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 80396908

$2,050,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace

4 Bedroom
4 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 78934722

$2,100,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace
laundry
pool

3 Bedroom
2.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 78798463

$2,195,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace
washer/dryer

4 Bedroom
3 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 78751226

$2,350,000
Shelter Island, NY

appliances
den
fireplace
garden
laundry

4 Bedroom
3.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 77670857

$2,495,000
Shelter Island, NY

appliances
den
ensuite
fireplace
garden

4 Bedroom
2.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 77674968

$2,495,000
Shelter Island, NY

appliances
den
ensuite
fireplace
garden

4 Bedroom
2.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 78073321

$2,700,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace
garden
granite counter
oven

4 Bedroom
3 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 78036090

$2,700,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace
garden
granite counter
oven

4 Bedroom
3 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 75845595

$2,950,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
pool

4 Bedroom
3 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 80469130

$2,950,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace
garden
gym
laundry

3 Bedroom
2.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 75504107

$4,550,000
Shelter Island, NY

appliances
den
ensuite
garden
pool

4 Bedroom
4.5 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 72611651

$4,850,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
fireplace
pool
tennis court
waterfront

3 Bedroom
2 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 80479346

$5,500,000
Shelter Island, NY

den
waterfront

6 Bedroom
6 Bathroom

Property image for Top 10 Houses for sale in Shelter Island Ny. ID 76455864

$6,500,000
Shelter Island, NY

balcony
den
fireplace
gourmet kitchen
pool

7 Bedroom
6.5 Bathroom

28 Properties for sale

1
2

Other popular searches

Search more listings